Ah, Halloween movies for kids. They usually come in two flavors: the kind that are so sugar-coated you feel like you need insulin after watching (Halloweentown, I’m looking at you), and the kind that sneak a little nightmare fuel into your childhood and stay with you until your thirties (Are You Afraid of the Dark?, Courage the Cowardly Dog). Luckily, R. L. Stine—literary sadist to millions of Goosebumps readers—decided to bless us with The Haunting Hour: Don’t Think About It, a movie that’s technically for kids, but feels like it was written for goth middle-schoolers who just discovered Hot Topic and really, really want to scare their little brothers.
It’s one of those rare “family-friendly” horror films that actually remembers to put the horror in there, right alongside the awkward product placement for Papa John’s pizza. Because nothing says “demonic two-headed monster” like dipping sauce.
Cassie: The Goth Hero We Didn’t Deserve
Emily Osment stars as Cassie, a teenage goth who moves to a new town and immediately decides to wage psychological warfare against everyone she meets. She pranks her little brother Max, torments her school’s reigning Mean Girl Priscilla, and dresses like she’s auditioning to be Wednesday Addams’ understudy. In other words, she’s the perfect protagonist for an R. L. Stine story—half clever, half reckless, and fully committed to ignoring warnings written in big, bold letters.
Cassie’s defining trait is that she thinks scaring people is hilarious. And you know what? She’s right. Watching cockroaches rain down on Priscilla during a Halloween piñata scene is so cathartic it should qualify as therapy.
The Shopkeeper: Tobin Bell Selling Books Instead of Murder
Then we meet the mysterious Halloween shopkeeper, played by none other than Tobin Bell—yes, Jigsaw from Saw. Instead of locking people in bear traps, here he’s hawking cursed books to angsty teenagers. And he does it with the same level of menace you’d expect from a guy who’s spent the last decade teaching people how to escape rusty pipes.
He insists Cassie take a book called The Evil Thing—and if a man who looks like he just got out of jury duty for the devil himself says “don’t read it out loud,” you probably shouldn’t read it out loud. Naturally, Cassie reads it out loud. Because without terrible decision-making, we wouldn’t have horror movies.
The Evil Thing: Monster Mash, But Make It Two-Headed
The monster, called “The Evil Thing” (points for blunt branding), is exactly the kind of creature you’d expect R. L. Stine to dream up while sipping warm milk and plotting childhood trauma. Two heads, one for sucking blood, the other for gnawing on your flesh like beef jerky. Imagine a demonic turkey with trust issues, and you’re halfway there.
Thanks to the wizardry of Gregory Nicotero and KNB FX (the same crew behind The Walking Dead and Narnia), the monster looks surprisingly gnarly for a PG movie. It’s rubbery and grotesque in just the right way, like something you’d find on the wrong aisle of Toys “R” Us. Watching it lurch around suburban basements while kids scream is pure nostalgic gold.
Sibling Rivalry: Horror’s Favorite Spice
Cassie’s relationship with her younger brother Max is central to the story, and it’s exactly the kind of sibling dynamic that makes parents want to day-drink. She pranks him, he tattles, and eventually she decides to weaponize a demonic text against him because he unplugged her computer. Honestly? Relatable.
But when the Evil Thing kidnaps Max, Cassie realizes maybe sibling abuse shouldn’t escalate to demonic possession. With the help of Sean (Cody Linley), the school’s discount Prince Charming, Cassie sets out to rescue her brother and prove that behind every sarcastic goth exterior is a big sister who occasionally gives a damn.
Priscilla: The Bully Who Deserved Cockroaches
Every good kid’s horror movie needs a villain who isn’t supernatural, and here it’s Priscilla—the Halloween Queen who spends her free time sneering at Cassie’s wardrobe. She gets exactly what she deserves: a shower of cockroaches in front of the entire school. Later, she gets kidnapped by the Evil Thing. Frankly, she earned both.
Papa John’s: Evil Has Extra Cheese
Yes, the product placement is as subtle as a jack-o’-lantern duct-taped to your face. Not only is the delivery guy woven into the story, but the film lingers on shots of the pizza box like it’s the true star. Nothing distracts from supernatural terror quite like watching kids gleefully stuff their faces with chain pizza while a monster lurks in the shadows. The only thing scarier than the Evil Thing might be Papa John’s customer service.
The Riddle: R. L. Stine Loves Wordplay Almost as Much as He Loves Scaring Children
Tobin Bell leaves Cassie with a riddle: “Two heads are better than one; that’s the way to get the bloody job done.” Which is basically Stine’s way of saying, “You kids better figure out how to make the monster eat itself, because I’m clocking out.”
And that’s exactly what happens. The kids lure the Evil Thing with roast beef blood (yes, mom’s leftovers save the day), and Max finally conquers his fear by chucking the blood onto the monster. Its two heads go full cannibal buffet, chomping on each other until the beast explodes in a glorious mess of yellow goo. Somewhere, Nickelodeon’s slime machine shed a tear of pride.
The Ending: Surprise, the Horror Never Ends
Cassie and her friends burn the book, celebrate their victory, and everything seems fine—until Dad picks the book out of the fireplace and mockingly reads it aloud. Boom. The Evil Thing is back, because parents never listen, and horror movies never truly end.
It’s the perfect conclusion for a kid’s horror flick: triumphant but still creepy enough to make you check your closet before bed.
Why This Movie Works
-
Scares for kids, laughs for adults. It’s spooky enough to thrill a 10-year-old, but cheesy enough to make adults chuckle through the ridiculousness.
-
Tobin Bell’s creepy shopkeeper. Who better to hand you cursed literature than the guy who invented murder puzzles?
-
Practical effects monster. In a world of cheap CGI, this rubbery abomination is a breath of slimy fresh air.
-
Sibling redemption arc. Cassie pranks Max into therapy, then saves him. Growth!
-
Dark humor baked in. Honestly, this movie knows it’s silly, and it leans into that with joy.
Final Verdict: Don’t Think Too Hard, Just Enjoy It
The Haunting Hour: Don’t Think About It is proof that R. L. Stine still knows how to deliver childhood terror with a wink and a smirk. It’s campy, it’s creepy, and it features a monster that looks like it crawled out of your worst midnight snack nightmare. Is it high art? Absolutely not. But for a made-for-DVD kid’s horror flick, it’s a surprisingly fun ride through haunted suburbia, complete with cockroaches, cursed books, and pizza advertising.
It’s a movie that reminds you childhood horror is best when it doesn’t pull its punches. And best of all? It’s a film where the lesson is clear: if Tobin Bell sells you a book with giant warnings not to read it, maybe—just maybe—don’t read it.
