Sarah Paulson has established herself as one of the most versatile and captivating actresses of her generation, and nowhere is this more evident than in her work on the anthology television series American Horror Story (AHS). Created by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk, American Horror Story has become a cultural phenomenon since its debut in 2011, with each season telling a different story, often with the same actors playing vastly different roles. Paulson has been a consistent presence on the show, delivering standout performances in a range of characters that showcase her remarkable ability to transform and adapt.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/sarah-paulson-season-1-6c71292215b44de4b5b5cc0458dad870.jpg)
In this article, we will delve into Sarah Paulson’s roles in American Horror Story, analyzing how she has brought each character to life and how her performances have contributed to the show’s enduring success. From her portrayal of a haunted journalist to a two-headed woman, Paulson’s work on AHS is a testament to her extraordinary talent and dedication to her craft.
Before her involvement in American Horror Story, Sarah Paulson had already built a solid acting career, with roles in both film and television. Born on December 17, 1974, in Tampa, Florida, Paulson moved to New York City as a child and eventually studied acting at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts. She made her Broadway debut in 1994 in the play The Sisters Rosensweig and quickly gained recognition for her talent.
Paulson’s early television work included roles in shows like American Gothic, Jack & Jill, and Deadwood. However, it was her role in American Horror Story that truly catapulted her to stardom and allowed her to explore a wide range of complex and challenging characters.
Season 1: Murder House – Billie Dean Howard
Sarah Paulson’s first appearance in American Horror Story was in its inaugural season, titled Murder House. In this season, Paulson played Billie Dean Howard, a medium with the ability to communicate with spirits. Billie Dean is called upon by Constance Langdon (played by Jessica Lange) to help her understand the supernatural events occurring in the haunted house.
While Billie Dean Howard is a relatively minor character in Murder House, Paulson’s performance is memorable for its subtlety and conviction. She portrays Billie Dean as a calm and composed figure, exuding an air of authority that makes her believable as someone who can navigate the spirit world. Paulson’s ability to convey a sense of otherworldliness without resorting to over-the-top theatrics set the stage for her future roles in the series.
Season 2: Asylum – Lana Winters
Paulson’s breakthrough role in American Horror Story came in the second season, Asylum, where she played Lana Winters, an ambitious journalist who becomes trapped in a nightmarish mental institution. Lana’s journey in Asylum is one of the most harrowing and emotionally intense arcs in the entire series, and Paulson’s performance is nothing short of extraordinary.
Lana Winters is initially introduced as a confident and determined journalist, eager to expose the horrors taking place at Briarcliff Manor. However, her investigation leads to her wrongful commitment to the asylum, where she endures unimaginable suffering at the hands of Dr. Arthur Arden (James Cromwell) and the sadistic Sister Jude (Jessica Lange). Paulson’s portrayal of Lana’s transformation from a victim to a survivor is both heartbreaking and inspiring.
One of the most powerful aspects of Paulson’s performance as Lana is her ability to convey the character’s resilience in the face of overwhelming adversity. Despite being subjected to torture, rape, and psychological manipulation, Lana never loses her will to survive. Paulson brings a raw intensity to the role, capturing the emotional toll of Lana’s experiences while also showcasing her strength and determination.
Lana’s eventual escape from Briarcliff and her rise to fame as an author and television personality is a testament to her unbreakable spirit, and Paulson’s portrayal of this journey is nothing short of masterful. Her performance in Asylumearned her widespread acclaim and solidified her status as one of the show’s leading stars.
Season 3: Coven – Cordelia Foxx
In Coven, the third season of American Horror Story, Sarah Paulson took on the role of Cordelia Foxx, the headmistress of Miss Robichaux’s Academy for Exceptional Young Ladies, a school for witches in New Orleans. Cordelia is the daughter of the Supreme witch, Fiona Goode (Jessica Lange), and her character arc revolves around her struggle to live up to her mother’s expectations while also protecting the young witches under her care.
Cordelia is a character defined by her compassion and empathy, traits that Paulson brings to life with grace and nuance. Throughout Coven, Cordelia grapples with her insecurities and feelings of inadequacy, particularly in comparison to her powerful and domineering mother. Paulson captures Cordelia’s vulnerability and inner turmoil, making her a sympathetic and relatable character.
As the season progresses, Cordelia undergoes a transformation from a passive and uncertain leader to a powerful and confident Supreme witch. This evolution is marked by several pivotal moments, including Cordelia’s self-inflicted blindness, which heightens her other senses and strengthens her magical abilities. Paulson portrays Cordelia’s growth with a delicate balance of strength and sensitivity, making her one of the most compelling characters in the season.
Cordelia’s journey in Coven is ultimately one of empowerment, as she steps into her role as the new Supreme and leads the coven into a new era. Paulson’s performance is a key factor in the success of this storyline, as she brings depth and emotional complexity to a character who could have easily been overshadowed by the more flamboyant figures in the series.
Season 4: Freak Show – Bette and Dot Tattler
In Freak Show, the fourth season of American Horror Story, Sarah Paulson faced one of her most challenging roles to date: playing conjoined twins Bette and Dot Tattler. Bette and Dot are two distinct personalities sharing one body, and Paulson’s ability to portray both characters simultaneously is a testament to her extraordinary talent.
Bette and Dot are introduced as the newest attractions at Elsa Mars’ (Jessica Lange) Cabinet of Curiosities, a struggling freak show in 1950s Florida. The twins have vastly different personalities, with Bette being sweet and naive, while Dot is more cynical and guarded. Paulson’s ability to switch between these two contrasting characters is nothing short of remarkable, and she brings a unique depth to each of them.
The technical challenges of playing conjoined twins were immense, but Paulson rose to the occasion with a performance that is both technically impressive and emotionally resonant. She captures the complex relationship between Bette and Dot, who are simultaneously dependent on and resentful of each other. Paulson’s portrayal of their conflicting emotions and desires adds layers of complexity to their characters, making them some of the most memorable figures in the AHSuniverse.
As the season progresses, Bette and Dot’s story becomes one of acceptance and self-discovery. Paulson’s portrayal of their evolving relationship is both touching and powerful, as the twins learn to embrace their differences and find strength in their bond. The dual performance required Paulson to navigate a wide range of emotions, and she did so with remarkable skill and precision.
Season 5: Hotel – Sally McKenna
In Hotel, the fifth season of American Horror Story, Sarah Paulson took on the role of Sally McKenna, a ghostly drug addict who haunts the Hotel Cortez. Sally is a deeply tragic character, consumed by loneliness and despair, and Paulson’s portrayal of her is both haunting and heartbreaking.
Sally’s backstory reveals that she was a songwriter who fell into a downward spiral of addiction and self-destruction. Her desperation for connection leads her to a tragic end, and she becomes trapped in the Hotel Cortez, where she continues to suffer in death as she did in life. Paulson captures Sally’s pain and anguish with raw intensity, making her one of the most emotionally compelling characters in Hotel.
One of the most striking aspects of Paulson’s performance as Sally is her ability to convey the character’s deep sense of loss and longing. Sally’s attempts to connect with others, even through violence and manipulation, are driven by her overwhelming fear of being alone. Paulson brings a vulnerability to the role that makes Sally’s tragic story all the more poignant.
Despite Sally’s dark and often disturbing actions, Paulson’s performance makes her a sympathetic character. She portrays Sally’s inner turmoil with such depth and authenticity that it becomes impossible not to feel empathy for her, even as she commits heinous acts. Paulson’s portrayal of Sally is a masterclass in balancing darkness with humanity, and it stands out as one of her most powerful performances in the series.
Season 6: Roanoke – Audrey Tindall and Lana Winters
In Roanoke, the sixth season of American Horror Story, Sarah Paulson took on the dual roles of Audrey Tindall, a British actress, and Lana Winters, the character she had previously played in Asylum. Roanoke is structured as a documentary-style show within a show, with Paulson’s character Audrey playing the role of Shelby Miller in a reenactment of the events surrounding the haunted Roanoke house.
Audrey Tindall is a somewhat comical character, and Paulson embraces the opportunity to bring a lighter, more satirical touch to her performance. Audrey is a dramatic and self-absorbed actress, and Paulson’s portrayal of her is both humorous and endearing. The character serves as a contrast to the darker and more intense roles Paulson has played in previous seasons, showcasing her range as an actress.
However, it is Paulson’s return as Lana Winters in the final episode of Roanoke that truly stands out. Lana is brought in to interview Lee Harris (Adina Porter), the sole survivor of the Roanoke nightmare. Paulson seamlessly steps back into the role of Lana, capturing the character’s maturity and gravitas after years of living with the trauma she endured in Asylum.
The juxtaposition of Audrey and Lana in Roanoke highlights Paulson’s ability to navigate between different tones and genres within the same season. Her performance as Audrey adds a layer of meta-commentary to the season, while her return as Lana provides a sense of continuity and closure for long-time fans of the series. Paulson’s versatility and commitment to her roles make her an invaluable asset to American Horror Story.
Season 7: Cult – Ally Mayfair-Richards
In Cult, the seventh season of American Horror Story, Sarah Paulson took on the role of Ally Mayfair-Richards, a woman grappling with severe phobias in the aftermath of the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Cult is a politically charged season that explores themes of fear, manipulation, and the rise of authoritarianism, and Paulson’s character serves as the emotional anchor of the story.
Ally is introduced as a liberal, upper-middle-class woman living in a seemingly idyllic suburban neighborhood. However, the election of Donald Trump triggers a resurgence of her debilitating phobias, including a fear of clowns, holes, and blood. As Ally’s mental state deteriorates, she becomes increasingly paranoid and isolated, leading her to question the loyalty of those around her.
Paulson’s portrayal of Ally is marked by its raw emotional intensity. She captures the character’s descent into fear and madness with a level of vulnerability and authenticity that is both gripping and unsettling. As the season progresses, Ally’s character undergoes a dramatic transformation, from a terrified victim to a powerful and vengeful force.
One of the most compelling aspects of Paulson’s performance in Cult is her ability to navigate the complexities of Ally’s character arc. Ally’s journey is one of empowerment, but it is also fraught with moral ambiguity. As she becomes more involved in the cult led by Kai Anderson (Evan Peters), Ally’s actions become increasingly ruthless, blurring the lines between victim and villain. Paulson’s nuanced performance allows the audience to empathize with Ally’s plight, even as she makes morally questionable decisions.
Ally’s transformation in Cult is a reflection of the broader themes of the season, which explores the ways in which fear and trauma can be exploited for power. Paulson’s portrayal of Ally is a powerful commentary on the dangers of radicalization and the complexities of human psychology. Her performance is a standout in a season that is often polarizing, showcasing her ability to bring depth and complexity to even the most challenging roles.
Season 8: Apocalypse – Venable and Cordelia Goode
In Apocalypse, the eighth season of American Horror Story, Sarah Paulson once again took on dual roles, playing both Wilhemina Venable, the strict and sadistic leader of Outpost 3, and Cordelia Goode, the Supreme witch from Coven. Apocalypse serves as a crossover between Murder House and Coven, and Paulson’s characters play pivotal roles in the season’s intricate narrative.
Venable is introduced as a cold and calculating figure, ruling over Outpost 3 with an iron fist. She enforces strict rules and harsh punishments, reveling in her power over the survivors of the nuclear apocalypse. Paulson’s portrayal of Venable is chilling and commanding, capturing the character’s ruthlessness and ambition. However, as the season progresses, it becomes clear that Venable’s harsh exterior is a mask for her deep-seated insecurities and desire for control.
In contrast to Venable, Cordelia Goode represents hope and resilience in the face of darkness. As the Supreme witch, Cordelia is determined to stop the Antichrist, Michael Langdon (Cody Fern), from bringing about the end of the world. Paulson’s portrayal of Cordelia is imbued with a sense of wisdom and strength, as she leads the coven in their battle against evil.
One of the highlights of Apocalypse is the confrontation between Venable and Cordelia, two characters who embody opposing forces in the season’s narrative. Paulson’s ability to distinguish between these two roles, each with their own distinct motivations and personalities, is a testament to her versatility as an actress. The contrast between Venable’s cold pragmatism and Cordelia’s compassionate leadership adds layers of complexity to the season’s exploration of good versus evil.
Cordelia’s journey in Apocalypse is also marked by moments of vulnerability, particularly as she grapples with her own mortality and the weight of her responsibilities as the Supreme. Paulson’s performance captures the emotional depth of Cordelia’s character, making her one of the most compelling figures in the AHS universe.
Sarah Paulson’s work on American Horror Story is a masterclass in versatility and transformation. Over the course of eight seasons, she has taken on a diverse array of characters, each with their own unique challenges and complexities. From the resilient Lana Winters in Asylum to the commanding Cordelia Goode in Apocalypse, Paulson has consistently delivered performances that are both captivating and emotionally resonant.
Meanwhile, check out our latest thriller FOLLOW THE WHITE RABBIT
