There are horror movies about ghosts, demons, chainsaw maniacs, and then there’s The Rats—a TV movie that decided the true apex of terror was a Macy’s knockoff overrun by genetically juiced rodents. Forget Freddy Krueger, nothing keeps you awake at night like the thought of mutant sewer rats loose in the lingerie department.
Originally set to premiere on September 17, 2001, the film was delayed after the September 11 attacks—probably not because of its sensitive imagery, but because Fox realized airing a movie this bad that week would have been an act of terrorism in itself.
Plot in a Nut (or Cheese) Shell
Mädchen Amick plays Susan Costello, the poor department store manager who has the misfortune of discovering that her biggest problem isn’t picky customers or inventory shortages—it’s the plague-carrying mutant rats in the dressing rooms. When a shopper gets bitten and contracts Weil’s disease, Susan hires Jack Carver (Vincent Spano), the best exterminator New York City has to offer. Which, in this movie, is like saying you’ve hired the best mime in Des Moines—highly debatable and not that useful.
Naturally, the rats aren’t just regular vermin. They’ve been altered by a DNA research trial, which means they’ve got a taste for human flesh and probably better résumés than the actors. Jack and his assistant Ty discover the infestation is spreading faster than a Manhattan Starbucks, but the city health department—represented by Susan’s ex, Ray Jarrett—wants to cover it up. Because, as every made-for-TV horror flick knows, the real villain isn’t mutant animals, it’s bureaucracy.
By the time the rats start swarming escalators, mannequins, and food courts, the only question left is whether Susan and Jack can stop the infestation before all of New York turns into a Times Square Chuck E. Cheese on bath salts.
Casting Choices: The Real Horror
-
Mädchen Amick (Twin Peaks) looks like she’s still wondering why she agreed to this instead of holding out for Mulholland Drive.
-
Vincent Spano as Jack Carver spends most of the film oscillating between “earnest pest control professional” and “guy who’d sell you a used car that might explode.”
-
Shawn Michael Howard as Ty gets the thankless horror sidekick role: crack a joke, wave a flashlight, die heroically. It’s practically union-mandated.
-
David Wolos-Fonteno as Ray Jarrett delivers his lines with all the conviction of a man who knows his paycheck clears whether or not he remembers his character’s name.
Special Effects: SyFy Before SyFy Was SyFy
The rats are presented in three forms:
-
Stock footage of actual rats – Cute, if you ignore the ADR squeaks at 120 decibels.
-
Rubber animatronics – Imagine Halloween store puppets duct-taped to RC cars.
-
Early-2000s CGI – Let’s just say if you’ve ever played Doom on a Windows 95, you’ve seen scarier graphics.
There’s one scene in which the swarm looks less like an army of rodents and more like a dark puddle of chocolate syrup oozing down the stairs. Willy Wonka would be proud.
Themes (If You Can Call Them That)
The film accidentally becomes a metaphor for late-stage capitalism: rats overrunning department stores while management denies everything in the name of profit. Susan might as well scream, “The vermin are eating my customers alive!” and Ray would still shrug and say, “But have you seen the quarterly numbers?”
There’s also the subtle environmental message: mess with nature and it messes back. But that message is drowned out by the louder theme: “Don’t shop at Garsons, shop at literally any competitor.”
Highlights of Unintentional Comedy
-
A rat attacks someone in the dressing room, and the victim’s reaction is more appropriate for a broken zipper.
-
Exterminators take a “rat sample” like scientists taking a moon rock.
-
A dramatic line—“They’re evolving!”—is delivered with such gravity you’d think the rats had unionized.
-
The climax features rats attacking mannequins, which look more terrified than the cast.
Say what?
You almost feel sorry for the rats. They were just lab animals, thrust into a world where their destiny is to star in a TV horror movie with Paris Hilton nowhere in sight. (This was 2002; Hilton could have saved it by showing up and saying, “That’s hot,” )
The real scare isn’t the gnashing teeth or glowing eyes—it’s the thought that someone greenlit this script and said, “Yes, America needs this.” In the hierarchy of horror monsters, these rats are somewhere between Gremlins 2’s Vegetable Gremlin and the killer turkeys from Thankskilling.
Why It Weirdly Works
Here’s the kicker: despite everything—the bad CGI, the flat characters, the rats that look like hairbrushes with teeth—The Rats is kind of fun. It’s schlock with ambition. It tries to give you urban dread, conspiracy thriller politics, and mutant monster mayhem, all wrapped in the comforting beige tones of early-2000s network television.
It’s the cinematic equivalent of stale movie theater popcorn: bad for you, too salty, but strangely addictive once you start munching.
