Tobe Hooper gave us The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, a low-budget nightmare that redefined horror. Thirty years later, he gave us Toolbox Murders—a film that redefined nothing except how long you can stare at Angela Bettis wandering down dimly lit hallways without filing a lawsuit for time theft.
It’s pitched as a remake of the trashy 1978 exploitation film, but instead of sleaze and grit we get occult symbols, missing rooms, and a killer named Coffin Baby—a name so dumb it sounds like a rejected GWAR mascot. This isn’t just a bad horror movie. It’s a reminder that sometimes your heroes should retire before they start handing out cordless drills like party favors.
Plot: Or, Why We Can’t Have Nice Apartments
The story takes place at the Lusman Arms, an old Hollywood hotel turned into apartments for people who apparently don’t mind mysterious noises, broken intercoms, and suspicious amounts of human teeth stuffed in the walls. A new couple moves in:
-
Nell (Angela Bettis): a jittery teacher who spends the whole movie looking like she smelled something foul, which, given the plot, might just be the script.
-
Steven (Brent Roam): her husband, a medical intern who’s so absent he might as well be a ghost tenant.
Nell befriends quirky neighbors, including Juliet Landau as Julia, who deserved a better death than being drilled like drywall, and Rance Howard as Chas, the cryptic old man who exists solely to mutter ominous things like, “The building is alive!” (No, sir, it’s just infested with bad writing.)
Tenants vanish, screams echo through the vents, and Nell finds an occult conspiracy involving missing fourth-floor apartments and runes carved into the walls. Meanwhile, a ski-masked maniac is murdering everyone with a nail gun, hammer, or whatever Black & Decker happened to sponsor that day. Eventually, we learn the killer is Coffin Baby, a deformed monster who apparently clawed his way out of his mother’s womb like he was late for brunch.
Characters: Now Available in Beige
-
Nell (Angela Bettis): She’s supposed to be our “final girl,” but she spends most of the movie scribbling runes on her arms and wandering around like a substitute teacher lost in a Home Depot.
-
Steven (Brent Roam): A medical intern who works long hours, leaving Nell alone in the building. Translation: he’s too busy pretending to be in ER to notice his wife is living in Poltergeist.
-
Byron (Greg Travis): The building manager who introduces new tenants and then becomes hammer fodder.
-
Chas (Rance Howard): The wise old neighbor who dishes out cryptic warnings, like a cut-rate Obi-Wan Kenobi. Spoiler: he gets thrown against a wall like a sack of laundry.
-
Julia (Juliet Landau): She vanishes halfway through, because this movie can’t afford to keep a real actress around for long.
-
Coffin Baby (Chris Doyle): The big bad. Imagine Jason Voorhees if he spent less time at summer camp and more time loitering in a Home Depot power tools aisle.
The rest of the tenants are basically numbers on a kill list. They exist to scream, get nailed (literally), or dangle from ropes until Coffin Baby gets bored.
The Toolbox Murders: Sponsored by Ace Hardware
Here’s the gimmick: the killer uses tools to murder people. That’s it. Hammer, drill, nail gun. It’s like watching a murderous episode of This Old House. At first, you think maybe there’ll be some creativity—death by belt sander? Impaled on a level? Beaten with a caulking gun? Nope. Just the usual blunt force trauma with the subtlety of a sledgehammer.
The gore isn’t even fun. It’s perfunctory, like the movie is sighing while stabbing someone. “Yeah, yeah, hammer to the face, whatever, moving on.” Even the 1978 original had more flair in its exploitation sleaze. This remake feels sanitized, like someone ran a slasher flick through HGTV.
The Building: Haunted by Dumb Ideas
The Lusman Arms is practically its own character, and like every character here, it’s dull. We’re told the architect was into the occult, carving runes into the walls to trap spirits, and hiding an entire townhouse inside the building. It’s basically the Winchester Mystery House if it were designed by a drunk Freemason with a coupon for concrete.
Missing rooms? Fine. Creepy history? Fine. But do we really need a subplot about secret societies mixing science and magic? By the time Nell discovers a hidden Hollywood shrine and a torture chamber, you half-expect Nicolas Cage to show up screaming about the National Treasure.
Coffin Baby: Worst Horror Villain Name Ever
Let’s linger on the name Coffin Baby. Imagine trying to terrify your audience with that. Freddy Krueger. Michael Myers. Leatherface. Coffin Baby. It sounds less like a killer and more like a novelty goth band that plays your cousin’s Sweet Sixteen.
The movie tries to give him a mythology: born of a dead mother, raised in secret tunnels, tied to the building’s occult runes. But the truth is simpler: he’s just a sweaty dude in a mask with access to a Lowe’s credit card. His big reveal moment doesn’t inspire fear—it inspires laughter, the kind you stifle in the theater so people don’t think you’re cruel.
The Ending: Runes, Guns, and Shrugs
The climax involves Nell realizing Coffin Baby needs the building’s magic to survive, which is horror-movie code for “we needed a third act twist.” There’s some chasing through tunnels, a fight in a room full of corpses, and then Coffin Baby is “killed” multiple times: buried in rubble, shot by police, hanged out a window. Each time, he pops back up like a slasher-themed jack-in-the-box.
By the final fade-out, you’re not scared—just exhausted. Coffin Baby is still alive, Nell is traumatized, and you’re left staring at your screen wondering if this is what Tobe Hooper meant when he said he wanted to reinvent horror.
Why This Fails Harder Than a Rusty Drill
-
Pacing: Endless hallway wandering. You could cut 30 minutes and lose nothing but Angela Bettis frowning at wallpaper.
-
Kills: Bland, uninspired, and repetitive. A toolbox full of potential reduced to three tools.
-
Villain: Coffin Baby is the least intimidating name since Babyface from Happy Death Day—except that movie knew it was dumb.
-
Plot Twists: Occult architecture and missing apartments sound cool in theory, but here they’re wasted like glitter on a corpse.
-
Legacy: This is from the director of Poltergeist and Texas Chain Saw. The fall from grace is almost as scary as the movie wants to be.
Dark Humor Takeaways
-
Coffin Baby proves the scariest thing about home renovation isn’t cost overruns—it’s shoddy screenwriting.
-
The Lusman Arms has more missing rooms than this script has missing logic.
-
If you’re going to name your villain Coffin Baby, at least give him a pacifier with spikes. Missed opportunity.
-
The toolbox itself has more personality than most of the cast.
Final Verdict: Screwed
Toolbox Murders (2004) is proof that even horror legends can build something crooked when handed the wrong blueprints. Instead of a terrifying remake, we get a limp mess where the only thing scarier than Coffin Baby is the idea of sitting through Toolbox Murders 2. Yes, they made one. No, you don’t want to watch it.
If you’re into DIY, skip this movie and assemble IKEA furniture in the dark—it’ll be scarier, bloodier, and you’ll still get more satisfaction.
