There are bad movies. There are offensive movies. And then there are movies like Cannibal (2006), Marian Dora’s feature-length debut that somehow manages to be both boring and revolting at the same time. It’s like if Silence of the Lambs and Cooking with Emeril had a child, and then that child grew up to eat itself.
Marketed as an “exploitation horror” film, Cannibal is based loosely—though not loosely enough—on the real-life case of Armin Meiwes, the German man who posted an online ad looking for a willing victim to eat. Spoiler: he found one. And spoiler for the movie: you’ll wish you hadn’t found this film.
The Premise: Swipe Left for Cannibals
The story, such as it is, follows “The Man” (Carsten Frank), a lonely German fellow whose hobbies include surfing cannibal chat rooms, watering his plants, and fantasizing about how best to sauté another human being. He eventually meets “The Flesh” (Victor Brandl), a suicidal guy from Berlin who volunteers to be eaten. Yes, it’s Grindr with a garnish of parsley and despair.
The two meet, bond, have awkward sex, and prance naked through the countryside like they’re filming a German yogurt commercial. Except instead of yogurt, the product placement is penis-frying.
The Penis Scene (Because of Course There’s a Penis Scene)
Let’s get to the infamous centerpiece. Cannibal builds to a moment where The Flesh insists The Man bite off his penis. Now, most horror films go for a jump scare. This one goes for a “jump scream.” The Man, however, can’t quite manage the dental work, even after The Flesh dopes himself up like he’s prepping for a dental cleaning.
So instead, The Man castrates him with a kitchen knife. It’s filmed with all the elegance of a late-night infomercial for the Ginsu blade: “It slices! It dices! It makes your dinner guests scream in agony!”
The two then attempt to fry and eat the severed penis. This scene alone proves why Germany doesn’t get invited to many international potlucks.
The Gore: Michelin-Star Misery
Now, you’d think a film about consensual cannibalism would at least commit to being shocking. Instead, Cannibal gives us endless minutes of mundane padding. Shots of The Man brushing his teeth. Shots of The Man eating soup. Shots of The Man staring at his computer like he’s stuck on dial-up. By the time the “horror” starts, you’re begging someone to be murdered—if only to move the plot along.
When it finally arrives, the gore is graphic but so poorly staged it looks like a butcher shop run by interns. There’s dismemberment, blood, and offal, but it’s filmed with such clinical detachment that it stops being horrific and just feels like watching your neighbor prepare venison. Except the venison is a man named Victor.
The Performances: Please Don’t Quit Your Day Jobs
-
Carsten Frank (The Man): Plays his role with all the charisma of a tax auditor. His cannibalistic obsession comes across less as terrifying psychosis and more like he’s annoyed his takeout order got mixed up.
-
Victor Brandl (The Flesh): Honestly deserves hazard pay for agreeing to any of this. His performance is essentially one long death rattle interspersed with moaning and defecating. Not exactly Oscar bait.
-
Manoush (The Mother): Appears briefly in the Hansel and Gretel framing device, then vanishes, presumably to escape this cinematic atrocity.
The Style: Art-House Horror, Emphasis on “Art”
Director Marian Dora clearly thinks he’s making high art. The film is full of long, lingering shots, grainy handheld camerawork, and a soundtrack that sounds like someone dropped a synthesizer into a swamp. Instead of being atmospheric, it feels like the world’s worst student film—pretentious, slow, and desperate to be taken seriously.
At times, it even flirts with surrealism. But surrealism works when there’s imagination. Here it’s just “let’s film a man sitting on the toilet for five minutes while ambient noise plays.” If David Lynch ever saw this, he’d sue for defamation of weirdness.
The Problem of “Consent Horror”
The biggest issue with Cannibal is that its premise deflates its horror. Most horror relies on victims fighting for survival. But here, the victim literally begs for his own castration and consumption. The tension is gone. Instead of fearing for him, you’re just impatiently checking your watch, wondering when he’ll finally bleed out so you can go home.
Even worse, the film has no insight, no commentary, and no sense of irony. It doesn’t examine obsession, loneliness, or deviant psychology—it just wallows in entrails like a pig in mud.
The Ending: Finger Licking Bad
After much dragging, vomiting, and dismembering, The Man finally kills The Flesh by stabbing him in the throat. Then he cooks him, eats him, places his severed head at the table like it’s Thanksgiving, and… masturbates to the memory. If that sounds like the punchline to a joke nobody should tell, that’s because it is.
The film ends with The Man wandering off, no wiser, no changed, just a lonely guy who now needs a new online friend. Cannibal 2: Electric Boogaloo, anyone?
The “Horror” That Wasn’t
So let’s tally the crimes of Cannibal:
-
It’s boring. A movie about consensual cannibalism should never drag, yet this one feels like it lasts seven years—the same time jump in the story.
-
It’s pretentious. Dora tries to dress gore in art-house clothing, but it’s like putting lipstick on a severed pig’s head.
-
It’s gross without purpose. Gore can be effective when it unsettles or shocks with intent. Here, it’s just gross for the sake of gross, like a toddler showing you something they found in the toilet.
-
It’s unscary. Not once does Cannibal evoke fear, dread, or even disgust strong enough to stick. Instead, it’s just numbing.
Final Thoughts: A Film Best Left Undigested
Cannibal is the cinematic equivalent of food poisoning: unpleasant going down, excruciating while it lasts, and leaving you with deep regret. It’s exploitation stripped of thrill, horror stripped of fear, and art stripped of purpose. It’s a long, dull trudge to an inevitable conclusion, decorated with genital mutilation and bowel movements.
If this was Marian Dora’s debut, it’s no wonder his name isn’t exactly etched into horror history. Watching Cannibal is like being trapped at a dinner party where the host insists on showing you home videos of his colonoscopy.
If you’re a gorehound completist who insists on watching every notorious title, fine—consider this your cinematic Brussels sprout. Otherwise, do yourself a favor: skip it. Or better yet, watch literally anything else. Even Cannibal Holocaust had a point.
Final Rating: Zero fried penises out of five. Worst served cold.
