There are bad movies, and then there are bad movies that strut around in period costumes, drenched in candle wax and sweat, insisting they’re masterpieces. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein belongs to the latter. It’s the kind of film that wants to be faithful to the novel, but only if “faithful” means “faithful like a drunk best man trying to give a wedding speech: emotional, loud, and shirtless for no reason.”
Kenneth Branagh directs, stars, and practically leaps into every frame like a man auditioning for both Victor Frankenstein and Fabio on the cover of a 90s romance novel. Robert De Niro plays the Monster—sorry, “the Creature”—in the most expensive Halloween makeup experiment ever committed to film. And Helena Bonham Carter plays Elizabeth, whose greatest crime is that she loved Victor enough to put up with his sweaty monologues.
Act One: The Birth of a Monster (and a Thousand Dutch Angles)
From the first frame, Branagh is already flexing. Literally. He cannot resist a chance to show off his glistening pecs as Victor Frankenstein, the brooding scientist who apparently conducts medical experiments only after oiling himself like a professional wrestler. His colleagues wear waistcoats; he looks like he’s ready to audition for Baywatch: Geneva.
Victor vows to conquer death after his mother dies. This could have been subtle. Instead, Branagh screams at the heavens like a man denied a parking spot. Then he goes off to university where John Cleese—yes, Basil Fawlty himself—plays his mentor, because nothing says Gothic horror like Monty Python explaining reanimation.
Branagh doesn’t so much direct as he lunges at the camera. Every scene is soaked in melodrama, spinning shots, and dramatic crane movements. It’s less “faithful adaptation of Mary Shelley” and more “Shakespeare in the Park if the park was on fire.”
De Niro, But Make It Patchwork
Robert De Niro, the man who gave us Travis Bickle and Jake LaMotta, now plays a stitched-together corpse with the demeanor of a sad hobo. To his credit, he actually tries. He mumbles, he broods, he even learns to read by spying on a family through a wall. Unfortunately, he looks like someone glued bacon to his face and called it prosthetics.
His Monster isn’t terrifying—it’s awkward. When he first staggers around naked, it’s less “tragic abomination” and more “your drunk uncle crashing through the garage at Thanksgiving.” You can almost hear De Niro thinking, I could be making a Scorsese movie right now.
Helena Bonham Carter: The Gothic Girlfriend Package
Elizabeth, Victor’s adoptive sister turned fiancée, is played by Helena Bonham Carter, which means she spends half the movie looking ethereal and the other half screaming while covered in blood. She loves Victor, which already marks her as a tragic figure. At one point, Victor literally brings her back from the dead by stapling her head to someone else’s body, and she STILL has better hair than Branagh.
Her final act—lighting herself on fire to escape the Monster and Victor’s nonsense—feels less like a tragic climax and more like the actress trying to get out of her contract.
Science! With Extra Sweat
The actual reanimation sequence is something to behold. Branagh, shirtless (again), runs around his lab like a man who’s late for spin class. He dunks body parts in amniotic fluid, hoists corpses into vats of electricity, and swings on ropes while screaming. It’s part mad science, part erotic Cirque du Soleil.
When the Creature finally comes to life, the scene is drenched in goo, sparks, and melodrama. The camera spins, Branagh howls, and you half expect someone to yell, It’s not a phase, Mom! The whole sequence is so over the top it makes Young Frankenstein look like a documentary.
Fidelity to the Novel: Or, Faithfully Boring
Critics often say this is the most “faithful” adaptation of Mary Shelley’s book. Sure, if by faithful you mean, “keeps the basic outline but drowns it in melodrama, adds unnecessary sex scenes, and forgets that subtlety exists.”
Yes, the Monster learns to read. Yes, Justine gets hanged. Yes, Victor chases the Creature across the Arctic. But instead of capturing Shelley’s philosophical dread about man, science, and morality, Branagh turns it into a two-hour workout video where everyone sweats, screams, and occasionally dies.
The novel was about man’s hubris. The film is about Kenneth Branagh’s hubris.
The Monster’s Revenge: Family Annihilation Edition
The Creature kills Victor’s little brother, frames the maid, and demands a girlfriend. When Victor refuses, the Monster rips out Elizabeth’s heart on her wedding night like a slasher villain auditioning for Mortal Kombat.
Victor, devastated but apparently still optimistic, decides to fix it by stitching Elizabeth’s head onto another corpse. She comes back, sees what’s been done to her, and immediately self-immolates. Honestly? Relatable.
The Arctic: Endurance Test for Both Characters and Viewers
The story ends with Victor pursuing his Creature to the North Pole, which is fitting since the movie feels like an endurance test for the audience too. Branagh collapses dramatically in the snow, De Niro weeps over him, and then throws himself onto a pyre. The Monster dies, Victor dies, and we die inside.
By the time the credits roll, you don’t feel sorrow—you feel relief.
Dark Humor Highlights
-
Branagh’s insistence on being shirtless in nearly every major scene. If Victor Frankenstein had spent less time oiling his chest and more time thinking, maybe none of this would’ve happened.
-
John Cleese with a fake jaw prosthetic, delivering serious medical advice while looking like he’s about to shout, “And now for something completely different!”
-
The Monster’s tragic arc is undercut every time De Niro speaks in a voice that sounds like he’s ordering pastrami at a New York deli.
-
Elizabeth’s fiery suicide: the most dramatic “I’m done with this relationship” exit in cinema history.
-
The Arctic finale proves once and for all that watching men yell at each other in the snow is only entertaining if one of them is named Jon Snow.
Final Verdict
Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein wants desperately to be high art—a faithful adaptation that captures the tragedy and horror of Shelley’s masterpiece. What it delivers is a sweaty, overwrought melodrama where Kenneth Branagh tries to out-act his own camera, De Niro looks embarrassed under a pound of latex, and Helena Bonham Carter sets herself on fire to escape the script.
It’s not terrifying, it’s not profound, and it’s not even unintentionally funny enough to be a cult classic. It’s just two hours of gothic overacting, stitched together like the Creature itself: a bunch of mismatched parts that never should’ve been brought to life.
