If you thought reality television was the lowest form of entertainment in the mid-2000s, Cruel World showed up to prove there was still plenty of room to dig. Directed by John Shepphird and starring Edward Furlong in what feels less like a role and more like a cry for help, this “slasher comedy” tries to skewer reality TV and ends up stabbing itself in the foot. Twice.
Edward Furlong: The Showrunner From Hell
Our villain is Philip Markham, played by Edward Furlong, who once saved humanity as John Connor and now can’t save a script written in crayon. Philip, bitter about losing on a fake Bachelor-style show called Lover’s Lane, murders the host and her husband, then sets up shop in the same house. His brilliant idea? Host a new “reality show” where contestants don’t get eliminated—they get eliminated.
It’s meant to be a satirical horror premise. Instead, it plays like Furlong showed up with bedhead, muttered a few lines about “my show now,” and wandered off to the craft services table. His menace level sits comfortably between “middle school substitute teacher” and “guy who forgot his shift at GameStop.”
The Contestants: Great Casting, Garbage Material
The “players” Philip lures into his blood-soaked pilot are a grab bag of reality-TV clichés: the jock, the flirt, the nerd, the edgy one, the good girl. They’re less “characters” and more “focus group responses.”
Two actresses, however, deserved so much better than this dumpster fire:
-
Susan Ward (Sunset Beach, Shallow Hal): She brings an actual screen presence to her scenes, even when the dialogue hands her lines like “Please leave your cell phone by the door” as if that’s supposed to be ominous. Ward could have been the sly, self-aware camp queen this film needed, but instead, she’s stuck in a narrative black hole where her talent gets smothered by cheap kills and Furlong’s endless mumbling.
-
Aimee Garcia (later to shine in Dexter and Lucifer): Watching her here is like finding a diamond in a puddle of spilled Monster energy drink. She’s charismatic, sharp, and easily one of the few contestants you actually want to see survive. Naturally, the script treats her like disposable cannon fodder, wasting her on clunky exposition and then discarding her in the same way bad reality shows discard the funny contestant too early.
It’s depressing to think that two genuinely skilled actresses were forced to do career push-ups in a movie that thought “locking contestants in coffins” was a metaphor.
The Snuff Film Angle: Edgelord Theater
The gimmick here is that Philip films all the kills as if he’s producing a reality TV show. Contestants are forced through challenges that make Fear Factor look classy, like trying to find keys in coffins or enduring endless nights of starvation. When they fail, Philip and his brother Claude (Daniel Franzese, sadly also wasted) dispatch them on camera.
It’s supposed to be commentary about voyeurism and our obsession with televised cruelty. But instead of biting satire, it’s like someone taped over The Real World with a freshman film student’s final project titled “Society is the Real Killer.” The violence is bloodless, the comedy lands like a wet sponge, and the “social critique” is about as subtle as a sledgehammer with glitter glue on it.
Jaime Pressly, Gone Too Soon
Jaime Pressly shows up as Catherine, the host of Lover’s Lane, and the one person who could have turned this into the campy trainwreck it should have been. Pressly has timing, charisma, and an innate sense of irony that the rest of the cast lacks. Naturally, she gets killed early, because why keep your best asset when you can let Edward Furlong monologue at a wall for another forty minutes?
Furlong, Franzese, and the Curse of Claude
Daniel Franzese (Mean Girls) plays Claude, Philip’s brother and reluctant henchman. He’s given the thinnest of arcs—developing a crush on final girl Jenny (Laura Ramsey)—and spends most of his screen time sulking and mumbling. The movie wastes Franzese almost as badly as it wastes Ward and Garcia, which is saying something.
And Furlong? He delivers his lines as though he’s reading ransom notes he wrote to himself. Watching him posture about running “his show” is less scary and more sad, like finding out the T-800 from Terminator 2 actually won.
Pacing and Direction: Reality TV Without the Editing
The pacing is molasses-thick. Entire stretches of the film consist of contestants wandering hallways, squabbling, or repeating “what’s going on?” like a broken record. Director John Shepphird never figures out if this should be a horror satire, a gorefest, or a parody, so it wobbles between them and lands nowhere.
The kills—supposedly the highlight of any slasher—are as uninspired as the dialogue. If you’re going to make a movie about snuff TV, at least deliver something grotesque or inventive. Instead, we get the cinematic equivalent of a PG-13 Halloween haunted house.
The Ending: Death by Text Message
The finale tries to leave us with a “chilling” reminder that Philip is still out there. Jenny escapes, Philip gets away, Claude gets arrested, and then—because subtlety is for other movies—Jenny later receives a text message reading: “Please Leave Your Cell Phones By The Door.”
That’s right. The terrifying final threat is basically the same wording you get when you go to a yoga retreat. The movie ends on a hand grabbing Jenny’s shoulder as she boards a monorail. A monorail. Nothing says horror like The Simpsonspublic transit gag.
Performances: Misery Loves Company
-
Edward Furlong: Looks like he lost a bet and this was the punishment.
-
Laura Ramsey: Brings all the emotional depth of someone waiting in line at Starbucks.
-
Daniel Franzese: Too talented for this material, stuck in a role that gives him nothing to do but sigh.
-
Susan Ward: Criminally underused. Could have elevated this into camp; instead, the movie buries her like one of Philip’s contestants.
-
Aimee Garcia: A bright spot that reminds you she’ll go on to much better things. Her survival instinct should’ve kicked in the moment she read the script.
-
Jaime Pressly: Shows up, makes you think “oh, this could be fun,” and then gets killed, taking the last shred of energy with her.
The Real Cruelty
The real “cruel world” isn’t Philip’s death game—it’s sitting through ninety minutes of this film knowing that Susan Ward, Aimee Garcia, and even Daniel Franzese are capable of so much more. They could have been the sharp, ironic edge this movie desperately needed. Instead, they’re buried under bad writing, limp scares, and Edward Furlong’s energy-draining vortex.
Final Verdict
Cruel World wanted to be a clever mashup of reality TV satire and slasher horror. What it delivered was a soggy mess that wasted good actors, insulted bad actors, and managed to be less entertaining than an actual episode of Flavor of Love.
Susan Ward and Aimee Garcia prove here that talent can survive even in the worst material—though watching them flail in this garbage heap is its own kind of horror. If you’re going to watch Cruel World, do so only as a cruel experiment on yourself.
