Lost in Space and in the Script
There are short films that pack more power into ten minutes than most features manage in two hours—then there’s Entity(2014), a 14-minute exercise in cosmic boredom masquerading as existential horror. Directed by Andrew Desmond and co-written by Jean-Philippe Ferré, Entity is a French short that somehow feels longer than Interstellar.
The premise sounds intriguing: an astronaut stranded in deep space drifts toward a mysterious, sentient nebula. The execution, however, makes you wonder if the real horror was the editing process. This is the kind of film where “nothing happens” is not a critique—it’s the entire point.
It’s like Gravity—if Alfonso Cuarón had replaced Sandra Bullock with a screensaver and decided plot was bourgeois nonsense.
One Astronaut, Zero Pulse
Alias Hilsum stars as “The Astronaut,” because apparently names are too emotionally taxing for this movie. Hilsum floats, spins, drifts, and occasionally gasps for air in what feels like a cross between interpretive dance and an Ikea assembly tutorial filmed in slow motion.
To be fair, acting alone in a vacuum (literally and figuratively) is tough. But there’s “quiet introspection,” and then there’s “I can’t tell if she’s alive or buffering.” Hilsum spends most of the runtime staring into space—again, literally and figuratively—while the film desperately tries to convince us that her inner terror is profound rather than inert.
The problem is that Entity mistakes stillness for suspense. Instead of feeling claustrophobic, the emptiness just feels… empty. Watching this astronaut spin in circles while whispering breathy nothings into the void is less terrifying and more reminiscent of watching a screensaver set to “Existential Crisis.”
The Nebula That Knew Too Little
Eventually, the titular “Entity” appears: a glowing, pulsing cloud of cosmic gas that looks like it was borrowed from the Windows 98 visualizer. Supposedly, this is the moment where awe meets terror, where humanity confronts the infinite. In practice, it looks like the astronaut is being stalked by a psychedelic jellyfish with commitment issues.
We’re told this nebula is “sentient.” What does that mean? Does it want to communicate? Consume? Collaborate on a SoundCloud album? The film doesn’t say. It just floats there, occasionally twitching, like a bored god trapped in a lava lamp.
You’d think a cosmic encounter between human and unknown would carry some emotional weight. Instead, it’s like watching a staring contest between two things that don’t blink.
The Sound of Silence (and Pretension)
Entity proudly touts itself as the first French short film mixed in Dolby Atmos—an impressive feat, assuming you can stay awake long enough to notice. Unfortunately, no amount of surround sound can disguise the fact that most of what you’re hearing is heavy breathing and the occasional “Mission Control? Do you copy?”
The sound design aims for immersive but lands somewhere around “ASMR for insomniacs.” The vacuum of space has rarely been this noisy, or this uninteresting. Every inhale is drawn out to operatic proportions, and every faint hum is treated like it’s a symphony of despair.
The score is the real villain here. It drones on, moaning in faux-spiritual tones that sound less like terror and more like a yoga retreat hosted by HAL 9000. If cosmic enlightenment were a ringtone, this would be it.
Visuals Without Vision
Let’s give credit where it’s due: Entity looks expensive. For a short film, the visuals are undeniably polished. The lighting is ethereal, the textures crisp, and the space debris floats convincingly enough to make you forget there’s no story attached to it.
But beautiful visuals without narrative are just screensavers with delusions of grandeur. Every frame screams, Look at me! I’m art! while the audience quietly whispers, But why?
It’s a common trap for visually gifted directors—mistaking pretty for profound. The film’s cinematography captures the emptiness of space, but it doesn’t explore it. It just keeps showing us the same slow pans, the same drifting astronaut, the same sparkly void, as if repetition equals revelation.
The nebula, our supposed antagonist (or god, or therapy session—who knows), glows with kaleidoscopic beauty, but there’s no emotional connection. It’s cosmic eye candy without flavor, like licking the Milky Way and realizing it’s made of tofu.
A Masterclass in Meaninglessness
At its core, Entity wants to be a meditation on isolation, mortality, and the fragility of human existence. Instead, it plays like an undergrad thesis film titled The Void: A Love Story.
There’s no dialogue beyond the opening distress calls, and while silence can be powerful, here it just amplifies the vacuum between intent and execution. The film mistakes vagueness for depth—every lingering shot and ambiguous metaphor feels like it’s trying to whisper, “This is important.” It isn’t.
The astronaut’s slow-motion death spiral is framed as a spiritual awakening, but it lands somewhere between 2001: A Space Odyssey and My Wi-Fi Is Down. You can practically feel the director nudging you: See? It’s about humanity’s insignificance. Unfortunately, it’s hard to feel cosmic insignificance when you’re mostly feeling boredom.
The Emperor’s New Space Suit
Entity has been selected for over eighty film festivals and won several awards for visual effects, which just goes to show that festivals love shiny things. And yes, technically, it’s impressive—like a screensaver rendered in 4K by a team of very earnest people.
But somewhere between the festival applause and the Dolby Atmos mix, someone forgot that films need to say something. Watching Entity is like being told a deep philosophical secret by someone who’s just learned the word “metaphysical.”
It’s not profound, it’s not haunting—it’s the cinematic equivalent of staring into the void and having the void yawn first.
Space, The Final Nap Frontier
There are two kinds of viewers who might enjoy Entity:
-
Those who genuinely believe silence equals genius.
-
Those who accidentally fell asleep and woke up during the credits.
Everyone else will spend the runtime wondering how a film about suffocating in deep space manages to feel less tense than assembling IKEA furniture.
Alias Hilsum deserves credit for keeping a straight face while floating through existential PowerPoint slides, but no amount of acting can save a film that confuses emptiness with enlightenment.
The Grand Finale (If You Can Call It That)
The climax—if one can use that term for something this limp—involves the astronaut drifting toward the glowing nebula and merging with it. The visuals suggest transcendence; the pacing suggests your Wi-Fi dropped mid-scene.
We’re supposed to feel awe, terror, or some cosmic emotion that transcends words. What we feel instead is relief that the credits are finally rolling.
As the music swells and the stars fade, you half expect a post-credits message: “Thank you for your patience.”
Final Judgment
★☆☆☆☆ — One star for the visuals, none for the experience.
Entity is undeniably pretty, but so is a lava lamp, and at least the lava lamp doesn’t expect a standing ovation. It’s a film that confuses “nothing happens” with “it’s profound,” and “slow pacing” with “it’s deep.”
In space, no one can hear you scream—but if you watch Entity, they might hear you snore.
