You don’t watch Private School because you’re in the mood for good cinema. You don’t watch it because you crave narrative structure or clever wordplay. You watch it because you’re thirteen and the world is a storm in your pants. You watch it because you’re home alone and the house is quiet except for the hum of the VCR warming up for war.
And in that war, Phoebe Cates and Betsy Russell are the twin explosions.
The thing starts out pretending it has something to say. A prep school romance. A rivalry. Some class tension. Maybe a story about innocence and rebellion. But five minutes in, a character is mooning someone, another’s trying to peep into a locker room, and you realize what you’re really watching: a two-hour symphony to the glory of the teenage libido.
This was the golden era of softcore disguised as comedy. The days when every R-rated teen movie was sold to desperate boys with the promise of two things: laughs and breasts. And Private School delivered both, though only one of those still holds up.
The laughs? Well, they’re quaint now. This was back when calling someone a “dork” was enough to bring down the house. There are fart jokes. There are pratfalls. Matthew Modine does his best as the awkward, smitten boyfriend, and Phoebe Cates plays the good girl with enough grace to elevate the material—if just barely.
But nobody watched Private School for the dialogue.
They watched it for Betsy Russell.
Sweet Jesus.
She’s the femme fatale in gym shorts. A woman in a world of girls. She doesn’t play Jordan; she owns Jordan. A lingerie wearing hurricane with the kind of eyes that said, “I will destroy you, and you’ll thank me for it.”
Her infamous horse-riding scene—topless, triumphant, and totally unnecessary—became legend. As a kid, you didn’t understand why that scene was there. As an adult, you realize it was there for you. To short-circuit your innocence. To remind you that cinema is sometimes less about storytelling and more about impact.
And boy, that hit like a truck.
Even now, decades later, the memory of that moment lingers like a song you can’t stop humming. It was the kind of scene that made you feel guilty and giddy and grown up all at once. Not pornography. Not art. Something in between. A pulpy middle ground where your body knew things your brain hadn’t caught up to yet.
And then there’s Phoebe.
She was every boy’s dream in the early ’80s. The cool girl with the sly smile and the too-perfect face. She wasn’t as wild as Betsy’s character, but that was the point. She was attainable, in that cruel, cinematic way that meant she’d never exist in real life. She had vulnerability. Heart. A softness that made you want to protect her, even if she was smarter and stronger than the guys chasing her.
The guys in the film are a collection of dorks, perverts, and dweebs. There’s a character named Bubba who spends the entire movie trying to see women naked. He’s basically a walking lawsuit. Today, he’d be thrown out of school and canceled on every platform known to man. But back then, he was comic relief. You laughed because you didn’t know any better. The whole film is soaked in that ‘80s innocence—a time when movies could get away with almost anything as long as they ended with a prom or a food fight.
The soundtrack tries to be cool. There’s some cheesy synth, a couple of horn-heavy numbers that feel like rejected Porky’stracks, and one or two songs that you’re pretty sure only existed for the movie. But it works. In a cheap, sleazy, wonderful way. Like putting cologne on a raccoon. It doesn’t make sense, but it’s trying hard, and you respect the hustle.
Watching it now, it’s like visiting your old bedroom and realizing the posters you thought were so badass are faded and curling at the edges. The jokes are stale. The plot is held together with gum and lust. But buried under all that is something real—something honest.
Private School doesn’t pretend to be more than it is. It knows it’s dumb. It knows it’s juvenile. It knows you came for the girls and stayed for the girls. But within that honesty is its charm. It’s a movie made for 13-year-old boys by 35-year-old men who still remembered what it felt like to be 13. And maybe that’s why it stuck.
Because we all had that moment. That awakening. That blurry Saturday night where everything changed. For me, it came in the form of Betsy Russell on a horse. For someone else, maybe it was Phoebe Cates twirling in front of a mirror. But Private School was a portal. A low-budget time machine into a world where the stakes were small but the emotions were enormous.
You didn’t care that the teachers were one-dimensional. You didn’t care that the female characters were either saints or sinners, virgins or vixens. At thirteen, you hadn’t been poisoned by film theory or social commentary. You just knew what made your blood boil and your heart race. And Private School delivered that in spades.
Today, you watch it with one eye on the remote. You cringe a little. You laugh at how easy it was to impress you. You see the flaws in the lighting, the clunky edits, the scenes that go nowhere. You realize the whole thing is stitched together with spit and sighs. But even now, there’s a strange magic in it.
Because the memory of being young never leaves you. It just changes shape.
And when that VHS tape hissed and whirred and finally flickered to life, it wasn’t just a movie you were watching—it was the beginning of knowing. Not in some profound philosophical way, but in that primal, urgent, oh-my-God-what-is-this kind of way.
Private School is a relic. A time capsule. A mess. A masterpiece. It’s a film that shouldn’t work, and maybe it doesn’t—but it did. It did exactly what it was supposed to do. It shocked you. Excited you. Molded a little piece of your brain that never really un-molded.
So yeah, it doesn’t hold up. The jokes are outdated. The plot’s a joke. The guys are morons. And most of the acting is like community theater meets adult magazine.
But give it this—it never lied to you.
It never pretended to be anything more than two hours of sweat, skin, and laughter. It gave you Phoebe Cates and Betsy Russell in the same film. And if you were thirteen, that was the cinematic equivalent of striking oil in your backyard. Pure, uncut bliss.
So here’s to Private School—the movie that made you feel something, even if it was just the uncomfortable shifting in your seat when your mom walked in during that scene. A film that belonged to its time and yours. A film that taught you nothing, but introduced you to everything.
Raise a drink to it, if only for nostalgia’s sake.
And if you ever come across it late at night on some forgotten channel or buried deep in the streaming weeds, give it a watch. Not for what it is—but for what it was.
A love letter to youth. A time bomb of libido. A sweaty dream you didn’t quite understand, but couldn’t look away from.
We should all be so lucky to have a movie like that.
-
🎬 Part of Our Phoebe Cates Retrospective
-
👹 Gremlins
-
🌴 Paradise
👉 Or read the full tribute: “Remembering Phoebe Cates”
