Every once in a while, a horror movie arrives that feels less like a slick studio cash grab and more like a ghost story whispered around a campfire—where you’re not sure if you’re supposed to scream, laugh, or nervously check if your kids are still alive in the other room. Bernadine Santistevan’s The Cry (La Llorona) is one of those strange little films. On paper, it sounds like yet another low-budget indie destined for the DVD bargain bin next to Leprechaun in the Hood. In practice, it’s an earnest, atmospheric attempt to translate one of Mexico’s most enduring urban legends into a modern New York detective story.
Yes, it made a whopping $21,427 at the box office—enough to buy maybe half a used Toyota—but the point isn’t the numbers. The point is that someone decided, “You know what Manhattan really needs? A murderous, weeping ghost mom drowning kids in puddles,” and then actually filmed it. For that alone, The Cry deserves applause.
La Llorona in the Big Apple
The legend of La Llorona has been terrifying generations of Latin American children who didn’t clean their rooms. Betrayed by her husband, she drowned her kids in a fit of rage, then spent eternity haunting rivers, lakes, and—apparently—the NYC sewer system. Because even the afterlife can’t resist gentrification.
In The Cry, detective Alex Scott (Christian Camargo, with a perpetually furrowed brow that says, “I regret my life choices”) and his partner Sergio Perez (Carlos Leon, effortlessly cooler) investigate a wave of missing children. Naturally, this is New York, so you’d expect the culprits to be mobsters, subway weirdos, or at least a clown with a balloon fetish. Nope. Turns out it’s La Llorona herself, dragging kids into the afterlife like a demonic babysitter who charges nothing but your soul.
The Cast: Cops, Curanderas, and Crybabies
-
Christian Camargo as Alex Scott: A detective who spends most of the movie looking like he’s either constipated or about to cry himself. Perfect casting for a movie called The Cry.
-
Carlos Leon as Sergio Perez: The partner with street smarts, comic timing, and the perpetual air of someone wondering how he ended up in a supernatural horror flick instead of a gritty cop drama.
-
Míriam Colón as Gloria the Curandera: The mystical grandma archetype. She shows up, drops cryptic lines about curses and reincarnation, and then leaves everyone more confused than when she arrived. It’s like consulting a psychic who only speaks in fortune cookie riddles.
-
Adriana Domínguez as Maria: A grieving mother whose face says “serious indie acting” while her dialogue sometimes says “soap opera energy.”
Honestly, for a low-budget production, the cast gives it their all. No one’s phoning it in—though sometimes it feels like they were calling from a payphone in 1997.
The Horror: Whispering Ghost Moms
Let’s be clear: The Cry doesn’t rely on jump scares, gore, or demonic CGI toddlers. Instead, it goes for atmosphere—slow pans of shadowy alleys, whispers echoing in the dark, and the distant sound of La Llorona sobbing like your drunk aunt at a wedding reception.
It’s spooky in the same way as hearing a baby cry on an airplane when you know full well there’s no baby on the flight. Creepy? Absolutely. Annoying? Even more so.
That’s not to say the scares always land. Sometimes, La Llorona feels less like an ancient evil force and more like a soggy mom who missed the PTA meeting. But the film deserves credit for trying to root the terror in cultural folklore instead of cheap Saw knockoff traps.
The Tone: Somewhere Between Gritty Cop Drama and Urban Legend Fanfiction
Here’s where things get weird. Half the time, the movie plays like a Law & Order episode where Ice-T is replaced by a curandera. The other half, it’s full-on supernatural folk horror with crying ghosts and reincarnation nonsense. The tonal whiplash is strong enough to give you neck cramps.
But oddly, that’s also what makes it fun. You never know if the next scene will feature police procedural dialogue about missing children—or a possessed woman sobbing in Spanish about eternal damnation. It’s like binge-watching True Detective and Goosebumps at the same time.
The Production Values: Indie Charm (and Cheapness)
Let’s not sugarcoat it: this movie looks cheap. Not Sharknado cheap, but definitely Lifetime channel experimenting with horror cheap. The cinematography tries its best with dimly lit New York streets and claustrophobic interiors, but there are moments where it feels like the cameraman accidentally smeared Vaseline on the lens.
The sound design, however, carries the day. The distant cries of La Llorona echoing through the city are legitimately unsettling. You may not be scared by the visuals, but that mournful wail will have you checking your faucets for ghost moms.
Why It Weirdly Works
For all its flaws—the uneven pacing, the occasionally clunky dialogue, the budget that couldn’t buy a Starbucks latte in Midtown—The Cry succeeds where many horror films fail: it has heart.
It’s trying. Earnestly, awkwardly, almost embarrassingly at times, but it’s really trying to tell a ghost story rooted in culture and grief rather than just churn out another torture-porn cash-in. You can feel the filmmakers’ passion, even if the execution sometimes feels like a student project with big ambitions and no money.
The Humor: Unintentional but Delicious
Here’s where the dark humor comes in.
-
Watching hardened detectives discuss La Llorona with a straight face is comedy gold. Imagine Columbo investigating Slenderman.
-
The crying ghost’s tragic backstory is moving—until you realize she’s basically kidnapping kids for eternity because she never got therapy. This is less a horror villain, more a walking PSA for mental health services.
-
The climactic scenes sometimes teeter on melodrama so over-the-top you half expect the cast to break into a telenovela monologue.
But you know what? That’s the charm. The seriousness mixed with the absurd makes it entertaining in ways the filmmakers probably never intended.
Final Verdict: A Cry Worth Hearing
The Cry is not a masterpiece. It’s not going to dethrone The Exorcist or even The Ring. But it’s also not a soulless, jump-scare-riddled mess like many of its contemporaries. Instead, it’s a scrappy little indie with cultural roots, decent atmosphere, and enough unintentional comedy to keep you awake.
If you go in expecting high art, you’ll be disappointed. If you go in expecting La Llorona to haunt New York like some aquatic Batman villain, you’ll have a great time.
So yes, it made less money than a lemonade stand, but it also managed to bring one of Latin America’s most famous legends to the screen with sincerity and a dash of absurdity. And really, what more could you want from a horror film called The Cry?
Verdict: The Cry is like hearing a spooky bedtime story told by a very serious uncle who doesn’t realize his flashlight makes him look ridiculous. Creepy, campy, heartfelt—and just entertaining enough to make you glad you pressed play instead of scrolling Netflix for the tenth time.
