There are films that haunt you. They linger in your memory, their atmosphere creeping under your skin, their stories whispering in the dark corners of your mind. Then there’s The Haunting of Hell House (1999), which haunts you in the sense that you’ll regret ever renting it and feel compelled to warn strangers at bus stops.
This American-Irish co-production was marketed as Henry James’ The Haunting of Hell House, because nothing screams literary horror like slapping an author’s name on a Roger Corman-funded tax shelter shot in Galway. Supposedly based on James’ short story The Ghostly Rental, the movie takes what could’ve been a chilling gothic tale and somehow transforms it into a straight-to-video dirge with the pacing of a funeral and the scares of a Scooby-Doo blooper reel.
The Plot: Misery, Abortion, and… Tax Write-Offs
Our “hero,” James Farrow (Andrew Bowen), is a young student who impregnates his girlfriend. In a panic, he pressures her into an illegal abortion—which promptly kills her thanks to the abortionist’s negligence. Tragedy! Guilt! Gothic torment! At least, that’s what the filmmakers want you to feel. Instead, you’re wondering if this setup was scrawled on the back of a napkin in a Galway pub five minutes before shooting.
From there, James spirals into grief, hallucinations, and the kind of ghostly visions you’d expect if you ate bad shellfish. He starts seeing his dead lover in a conveniently haunted house, then turns to Professor Ambrose (Michael York), a man whose family tragedies apparently qualify him as an expert in supernatural counseling.
Ambrose himself is tormented by visions of his dead daughter, which sounds compelling—until you realize the ghosts are less terrifying apparitions and more “actors covered in pale makeup loitering in a badly lit hallway.”
Michael York, Why Are You Here?
The biggest mystery isn’t the ghostly rental—it’s why Michael York agreed to this project. Here’s a man who’s been in Cabaret and Logan’s Run, reduced here to wandering through dim sets and staring at the middle distance like he’s mentally rehearsing Shakespeare to survive.
York plays Professor Ambrose as if he knows he’s trapped in a Roger Corman production but refuses to lose his dignity. Unfortunately, dignity doesn’t survive long when your co-stars are chewing scenery like it’s their last meal, and the script gives you lines like: “The dead do not rest in Hell House.”
Spoiler: the audience doesn’t rest either.
The Acting: Somewhere Between Soap Opera and Séance
Andrew Bowen as James Farrow spends most of the film looking constipated, which I suppose is his way of conveying guilt. Claudia Christian shows up as Lucy, because every Victorian ghost story apparently requires a woman to look sultry while sighing heavily. Jason Cottle as Fletcher might as well have wandered in from another movie entirely—possibly a TV drama about accountants.
And then there are the ghosts, who are supposed to radiate supernatural menace but instead resemble theater kids rehearsing Macbeth with Halloween makeup and access to a fog machine.
Production Values: Roger Corman Strikes Again
Shot at Roger Corman’s Concorde Anois studio in Galway, the film looks like it was made with leftover sets from a Dracula spoof and lighting borrowed from a pub basement. The cinematography is so dark you’ll think your TV is broken. The pacing is so leaden it feels like a séance where everyone fell asleep mid-chant.
And then there’s the backstory: investors were promised profits thanks to Irish tax write-offs, only for the authorities to later claim Merlin Films Group didn’t follow the rules. Imagine explaining to your accountant: “Yes, I lost money on a haunted house movie, but technically it was educational. Michael York was in it.”
Atmosphere, or Lack Thereof
Henry James’ The Ghostly Rental is a tale of grief, guilt, and spiritual comeuppance. This adaptation is a tale of actors wandering through dimly lit hallways, punctuated by jump scares that couldn’t frighten a toddler. The film is so obsessed with fog and shadows that half the time you can’t tell if a character is being haunted or just looking for the bathroom.
Instead of tension, we get repetition: James sees his girlfriend’s ghost. Ambrose sees his daughter’s ghost. Somebody stares into a mirror. Somebody gasps. Repeat for 80 minutes until the credits roll and you thank whatever deity you worship that it’s over.
Variety Was Right
Brendan Kelly of Variety summed it up: “There’s a decent yarn lurking in here somewhere, though it’s smothered by remarkably bad acting, much too dark lensing and leaden pacing.” That’s critic-speak for: “This film sucks, but politely.” I’d put it less diplomatically: The Haunting of Hell House is like being locked in confession with a priest who won’t stop droning, while random goth teenagers wave flashlights at you from the corner.
Missed Opportunities
This could have been good. A Henry James adaptation with Michael York in the lead? Gothic atmosphere? Ireland’s moody landscapes? Instead, we got:
-
A haunted house that looks like it was decorated by the clearance aisle at Spirit Halloween.
-
A script that mistakes “dreary” for “serious.”
-
A story that could’ve explored guilt and repression but chose instead to wallow in cliché.
The scariest thing about this movie isn’t the ghosts. It’s realizing someone greenlit it thinking it would sell VHS tapes.
Final Verdict
The Haunting of Hell House isn’t so much haunting as it is exhausting. It’s a dreary, joyless slog through foggy sets, bad acting, and squandered potential. Michael York tries valiantly to elevate the material, but even he can’t save a movie that feels like it was produced as a tax write-off rather than a genuine attempt at horror.
Henry James deserved better. Ghost stories deserved better. Frankly, Ireland deserved better.
At 82 minutes, it’s mercifully short, but it still feels like purgatory stretched into real time. If you want gothic atmosphere and psychological horror, read the short story or rewatch The Innocents. If you want to waste an evening on a bad ghost movie with the faintest whiff of literary respectability, this one’s all yours
