Junji Ito writes horror manga so disturbing it makes you rethink every shadow in your house. Japanese studios then adapt his work into films so limp and lifeless that you start rethinking whether you should’ve just stared at a blank wall instead. Enter Tomie: Replay, the second film in the Tomie series and proof that horror sequels multiply like gremlins fed after midnight: wet, weird, and reeking of regret.
This movie’s central conceit is simple: Tomie can regenerate from even the tiniest fragment of herself, which in Ito’s manga is terrifying. In Replay, though, the big horror reveal is… a head popping out of a little girl’s stomach like a demonic Kinder Egg surprise. Instead of recoiling in terror, you just sort of shrug and think, “Well, at least it wasn’t a Furby.”
The Plot: Tomie by Way of Daytime Soap
The film kicks off with ER doctors performing emergency surgery on a six-year-old whose belly is bulging like she ate three watermelons whole. They cut her open and—surprise!—there’s a living, talking head inside. It introduces itself as “Tomie,” because nothing kills the suspense faster than the monster literally doing roll call.
The doctors, instead of fainting or fleeing like human beings, just plop her into a tank of alkaline solution in the hospital basement like she’s a neglected Sea-Monkey kit. Immediately, the staff starts disappearing, because apparently being in the same room as Tomie is like getting secondhand smoke for your soul.
Meanwhile, Takeshi (the kind of friend who eats your food and steals your girlfriend) meets a fully regenerated, naked Tomie wandering the halls. Instead of screaming, he thinks, “Yes, this is fine. I’ll just take this feral murder-demon home like a stray cat.” Naturally, he spirals into jealous obsession, because Tomie’s main power isn’t just regeneration—it’s turning men into horny, murderous idiots.
Parallel to this nonsense, we meet Yumi, daughter of the missing hospital director. She teams up with Fumihito, who’s recovering from an unspecified illness that may or may not just be “bad script fatigue.” They both realize they’re looking for Tomie, which is a red flag because no good night ever starts with, “Hey, want to hunt down the immortal succubus that ruins everything she touches?”
From here, the movie wanders like a drunk raccoon through alleys of exposition: Tomie’s cells infected doctors, Tomie came from a transplanted kidney, Tomie makes men stabby, Tomie wrote you a love note from beyond the grave—blah, blah, blah. By the climax, Yumi and Fumihito face off with Tomie in the hospital again. Fumihito suddenly grows a spine, chops her head off, and burns the body. Everyone sighs in relief like that’s going to stick. (Spoiler: it won’t. Tomie is basically the Energizer Bunny with better hair.)
The Characters: Meat Puppets with Dialogue
-
Yumi (Sayaka Yamaguchi): The protagonist, allegedly. Her main function is reading her dad’s diary and looking increasingly confused. Her emotional range is “slightly worried” to “mildly more worried.”
-
Tomie (Mai Hōshō): The titular nightmare. Supposed to be magnetic, seductive, and terrifying. In this movie? She’s a sulky exchange student with scissors fetish cosplay.
-
Fumihito (Yōsuke Kubozuka): Starts as sickly patient, ends as “guy with machete.” His arc has the emotional depth of a puddle.
-
Takeshi (Masatoshi Matsuo): Tomie’s disposable simp of the week. Falls for her, kills her, goes insane, rinse and repeat. He’s basically a PSA for why you shouldn’t talk to naked strangers.
-
Dr. Tachibana (Kenichi Endo): Only doctor with the good sense to realize this situation is cursed, so he promptly kills himself. Honestly the most relatable character.
The Horror: Less Ito, More “Oh.”
In the manga, Tomie is cosmic dread wrapped in beauty—a metaphor for obsession and the way toxic people ruin lives. In Replay, she’s more like an annoying roommate who won’t stop stealing your shampoo.
The film tries for body horror but ends up looking like discount Halloween props: rubber heads, ketchup blood, and acting so stiff you’d think everyone was allergic to emotion. The one halfway unsettling image—Tomie’s head growing out of a child’s stomach—is squandered immediately because the head starts talking. Imagine watching The Exorcist if Regan paused mid-vomit to introduce herself with, “Hi, I’m Linda.”
As for scares? The only real terror is realizing you’ve still got forty minutes left.
Production Values: Basement Chic
Junji Ito’s stories drip with atmosphere—claustrophobic, surreal, grotesque. This movie? It looks like it was shot in a hospital that had already gone out of business. The lighting is either “blinding fluorescent bulb” or “we forgot to turn on the camera flash.” The score is generic horror strings you could download from a royalty-free site labeled “Spooky.mp3.”
The pacing is glacial. Scenes drag on forever, padded with long silences where you can practically hear the actors thinking, “Is this in the script, or did the director just forget to yell cut?”
Why It Fails (With Bonus Sarcasm)
-
Tomie isn’t scary here. She’s supposed to be this irresistible Lovecraftian femme fatale. Instead, she’s like a chain-smoking aunt who crashes on your couch and drains your liquor cabinet.
-
The men’s obsession makes no sense. Takeshi sees a blood-soaked murder demon and immediately decides, “Yes, this is girlfriend material.” Honestly, the true horror is the dating pool.
-
Exposition overload. Half the movie is people reading diaries, journals, or notes. Nothing kills momentum faster than watching characters catch up on their reading list.
-
No escalation. Tomie regenerates, seduces, repeats. There’s no rising tension—just a grim loop of bad decisions.
-
Cheap look. The gore effects are laughable, the sets are dull, and the cinematography feels like someone’s first camcorder project.
The Only Unintentional Comedy
-
The alkaline solution tank. Instead of menacing, it looks like Tomie is stuck in a giant pickle jar.
-
The funeral note. Imagine attending your dad’s funeral and getting a flirty note from the undead woman who indirectly killed him. Peak awkward.
-
The finale. Fumihito lops Tomie’s head off and burns her body. Great plan, champ—except every fan of the series knows Tomie regenerates from a single eyelash. That’s like trying to kill mold by sneezing on it.
Final Verdict: Flatline Horror
Tomie: Replay is a horror sequel that feels less like a movie and more like a filler episode stretched to 90 minutes. It takes one of Junji Ito’s most haunting creations and turns her into a tedious rerun. It’s not scary, it’s not stylish, and it’s not even so-bad-it’s-good. It’s just… flat.
If Tomie is eternal, this movie is proof that bad adaptations might be eternal too. Instead of cosmic dread, we’re left with cosmic boredom, padded with diary entries and rubber heads.
