By now, Friday the 13th holds a place in horror history simply because of what came after it. The hockey mask, the machete, the legend of Jason Voorhees – they’re embedded in pop culture. But revisit the original 1980 film, and you’ll find something far removed from the image you’re likely picturing. No Jason. No mask. No iconic kills. Instead, what you get feels closer to a cheaply made TV movie trying to ride the coattails of Halloween, only with a bloodier twist and cuter girls.
Let’s call it what it is: Friday the 13th is a knockoff. A well-timed, cleverly marketed knockoff, sure, but a knockoff nonetheless. Released just two years after John Carpenter’s Halloween, Sean S. Cunningham’s film borrows the same premise — a group of young people being stalked and killed off one by one — and strips it of any atmosphere, restraint, or thematic weight. What’s left is an exercise in formula, one that hasn’t aged well.
No Jason, No Real Identity
Here’s the thing: Friday the 13th doesn’t even feature Jason Voorhees as the killer. That iconic figure doesn’t truly emerge until Part 2, and the hockey mask doesn’t show up until Part 3. In the first film, the killer is (spoiler for the three people who haven’t seen it yet) Pamela Voorhees, Jason’s mother, driven mad by her son’s drowning years before. It’s an interesting twist, but one that comes so late and so out of nowhere that it feels more like a writing gimmick than a payoff.
This raises a fair question: is Part 2 the real start of the Friday the 13th franchise? Arguably, yes. That’s when Jason steps into the spotlight, burlap sack and all, and begins the blood-soaked journey that defines the series. Part 1, by comparison, is a setup — a prequel disguised as a slasher — with very little of what makes the series iconic.
Aesthetic Shortcomings
Where Halloween relied on atmosphere, clever camera work, and a haunting score, Friday the 13th settles for flat lighting, wooden performances, and a score that tries to be spooky but sounds like an out-of-tune Psycho tribute. The direction is pedestrian, the kills are often telegraphed and repetitive, and outside of Tom Savini’s makeup effects (which are admittedly solid), there’s little here that sticks.
The pacing doesn’t help either. The film takes its time getting going, and then rushes to its conclusion, capped by a twist that lands somewhere between silly and surreal. It wants to be gritty, but never builds real dread. It wants to be shocking, but often comes off more like an after-school special gone wrong.
The Cast: A Few Bright Spots
If there’s anything that Friday the 13th does better than Halloween, it might be the casting — and that’s strictly in terms of 1980s eye candy.
For all of Friday the 13th’s clunky execution and flat dialogue, the film does manage to assemble a group of young actresses who, in retrospect, deserve more credit for carrying much of its limited emotional weight. While none of them were household names, many left a lasting impression — in some cases, far more than the film’s writing gave them room for.
Adrienne King as Alice, the designated Final Girl, turns in a performance that’s often better than the material she’s given. She brings a quiet strength and nervous edge to the role, which is essential considering how long the camera lingers on her in the final act. King’s Alice isn’t the most dynamic character in the franchise, but she’s believable as a survivor — someone who doesn’t initially seem capable of fighting back, yet does when backed into a corner. King also deserves credit for grounding the final confrontation with Pamela Voorhees in something resembling emotional realism. You feel her fear, her confusion, her exhaustion — even if the story doesn’t always support her.
Then there’s Robbi Morgan as Annie, the film’s most endearing presence — and arguably its biggest casting misstep. She’s introduced early with such charm and likability that one assumes she’ll be the Final Girl. She’s upbeat, relatable, quick to smile, and exudes a warmth that stands out in a cast of relative newcomers. Her early death, though now iconic in its shock value, feels like a waste. Frankly, Morgan had all the ingredients to be the lead, and her demise is a reminder of how often slasher films subvert expectations — sometimes at the cost of their own emotional stakes.
Jeanine Taylor’s Marcie brings a quieter, more introspective energy to the film. In one of the rare moments where the script lets a character breathe, Marcie shares a childhood dream about rain turning to blood — a small, eerie detail that adds texture. Taylor’s performance feels natural, a bit aloof maybe, but grounded. Her fate — dispatched mid-shower — is one of the film’s more memorable kill scenes, due in part to her understated vulnerability.
Laurie Bartram as Brenda plays the voice of reason among the counselors — thoughtful, responsible, and far less impulsive than some of the others. She’s got the right energy for someone trying to keep the chaos at bay. In many ways, Brenda is the “sleeper” of the group: calm, capable, and underutilized. Bartram’s acting is subtle, even when the script reduces her to just another scream in the dark.
Finally, Debra S. Hayes as Claudette, who only appears in the film’s 1958 prologue, leaves a stronger impression than one might expect from such a brief role. Her wide-eyed innocence and brief on-screen romance with Barry make the film’s cold open resonate more than it should. There’s something poetic about the way her brief life is extinguished — she, along with Barry, becomes the seed of vengeance that ultimately gives birth to the franchise.
It’s a curious thing, really: Friday the 13th may not have given these actresses rich characters, but each brought a unique energy that helped elevate a paper-thin script. And in hindsight, it’s Robbi Morgan — the wrong girl killed too soon — who haunts the film most. She had the charisma, the presence, and the look of a franchise anchor. But that’s the chaos of the slasher world: wrong time, wrong place, right performance — and gone far too early.
Kevin Bacon is here too, in one of his earliest roles, but he’s mostly forgettable until his spectacularly gory death scene — perhaps the most memorable moment in the film.
A Franchise in Search of an Identity
It’s odd to think that one of horror’s biggest franchises started with such an awkward misfire. Friday the 13th is remembered more for what it launched than what it actually delivered. And maybe that’s okay. The film was made on a small budget, turned a massive profit, and showed that audiences were hungry for slashers — even if they were shallow, blood-soaked, and derivative.
Still, nostalgia and reputation can’t disguise the truth: the original Friday the 13th just isn’t that good. It lacks the elegance of Halloween, the menace of Texas Chain Saw Massacre, or even the wild energy of The Evil Dead. Instead, it feels like a blueprint sketched on a napkin, filled in with clichés and a few buckets of stage blood.
The Verdict
If you’re watching Friday the 13th for historical reasons, or as a completionist, there’s merit to it. But as a standalone film, it’s hard to defend. The scares are limp, the killer reveal is unearned, and the legacy it spawned overshadows its own limited value. By the time the end credits roll, you’re left with one thought: the real Friday the 13th began with Jason — and he doesn’t show up here.
Final Score: 4.5/10
A curio of horror history, more interesting as a franchise origin story than an actual horror film. Watch it once, then move on to Part 2.
🔪 The Friday the 13th Retrospective Series
A look back at every machete swipe, scream, and sequel in the Friday the 13th franchise:
-
Friday the 13th Part 2 (1981) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-part-2-1981-the-birth-of-jason-the-middle-child-of-the-franchise/
-
Friday the 13th Part III (1982) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-part-iii-1982-mask-on-shirt-off-and-body-count-rising/
-
Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter (1984) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-the-final-chapter-1984-the-best-lit-death-march-yet/
-
Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning (1985) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-part-v-a-new-beginning-1985/
-
Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives (1986) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-part-vi-jason-lives-1986/
-
Friday the 13th Part VII: The New Blood (1988) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-part-vii-the-new-blood-1988/
-
Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan (1989) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-part-viii-jason-takes-manhattan-1989/
-
Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday (1993) – https://pochepictures.com/jason-goes-to-hell-1993-the-body-hopping-butcher-and-the-death-of-a-slasher/
-
Jason X (2001) – https://pochepictures.com/jason-x-2001-a-space-odyssey-of-slashes-and-silliness/
-
Freddy vs. Jason (2003) – https://pochepictures.com/freddy-vs-jason-2003-when-nightmares-meet-crystal-lake/
-
Friday the 13th (2009) – https://pochepictures.com/friday-the-13th-2009-the-brutal-reboot-that-forgot-the-soul/
