There are haunted house movies that terrify you. There are haunted house movies that unsettle you. And then there’s The Haunting (1999), a haunted house movie that mostly makes you admire the drapery while wishing Owen Wilson’s head would just get lopped off already. Spoiler: it eventually does, but by then you’re too numb to care.
Directed by Jan de Bont (Speed, Twister)—a man who clearly believes special effects are scarier than atmosphere—this $80 million adaptation of Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House is a two-hour screensaver of gothic CGI and melodrama that manages to drain all the dread out of one of the greatest horror novels ever written.
The Premise: Fear Study or Interior Design Showcase?
The setup is simple enough. Dr. David Marrow (Liam Neeson, phoning in his lines like he’s already imagining his future “Taken” monologues) invites insomniacs to Hill House under the guise of a sleep study. Really, he’s studying fear. What better way to study fear than to trap Lili Taylor, Owen Wilson, and Catherine Zeta-Jones in a house that looks like Liberace’s mausoleum and watch them flail?
Cue the spooky happenings: blood writing on the walls, ghostly kids, and doors that slam harder than a college freshman’s after an awkward walk of shame. Unfortunately, none of it is frightening. It’s all so drenched in CGI that you half expect Hugh Crain’s ghost to pause mid-attack to advertise AOL free trial CDs.
Lili Taylor: Nell the Martyr
Lili Taylor is a phenomenal actress (I Shot Andy Warhol, Mystic Pizza)—but here she’s saddled with Eleanor “Nell” Vance, a character who spends 114 minutes oscillating between whispering about children’s ghosts and staring slack-jawed at the woodwork.
Nell is supposed to be the heart of the story, a sensitive woman caught in the house’s grip. Instead, she comes across as the kid in class who insists the Ouija board “really moved on its own.” By the end, when she declares “I’m not afraid anymore!” to Hugh Crain’s ghost, it doesn’t feel like triumph. It feels like someone begging the CGI department to stop rendering.
Liam Neeson: Scientist of Blah
Liam Neeson as Dr. Marrow spends most of the film looking like he can’t believe he’s here. This is Qui-Gon Jinn’s gap year gone horribly wrong. His character arc? Lying about the experiment, then realizing—oops—the house is actually haunted.
By the third act, when he’s nearly drowned by a sentient statue, you can practically hear him thinking: Please, George Lucas, call me back. I’ll swing a lightsaber for free.
Catherine Zeta-Jones: Glamour in the Gloom
Catherine Zeta-Jones plays Theo, the bisexual, bohemian foil to Nell’s repressed innocence. On paper, she should be sizzling. On screen, she struts around in flowing blouses like she’s auditioning for a haunted Sex and the City spin-off.
Theo’s bisexuality is mentioned once and then ignored—Hollywood’s 1999 way of saying “representation.” Her real role? Delivering lines like “Nell, are you okay?” fifty times while glaring at the wallpaper. Honestly, the wallpaper gets more character development.
Owen Wilson: Wow, I Lost My Head
Then there’s Owen Wilson as Luke, the comic relief frat boy. His entire performance is “Wow, this house is spooky” in various registers. At one point, he actually yells “That door’s alive!” as if he’s discovered meth.
Luke’s death is the film’s big “shocker.” He gets decapitated by a giant lion-head chimney flue. It’s less horrifying and more like watching Night at the Museum cut for violence. You half expect Ben Stiller to wander in and ask the ghost to chill out.
The House: Overdesigned, Underwhelming
The real star of the film is Hill House itself, which is so elaborately overdesigned it feels less like a set and more like a theme park ride. The ceilings tower higher than a cathedral, every wall is dripping in grotesque ornamentation, and statues leer from every corner.
Problem is, the design is so busy that you stop being scared and start playing Where’s Waldo? with the gargoyles. Instead of menace, the house exudes Pottery Barn Gothic. When the house finally “comes alive,” it looks like someone let a Windows 98 screensaver escape.
The CGI: Haunted by 1999
Ah, 1999 CGI. A magical time when filmmakers believed computer effects could replace practical scares. Instead, we get giant faces pushing through walls like Stretch Armstrong, ghost children who look like rejected Casper extras, and a bronze door climax that feels like an animated cutscene from a failed PlayStation 1 game.
The 1963 Haunting terrified audiences with shadows and sound design. The 1999 version terrifies you with the thought that this cost $80 million.
The Villain: Hugh Crain, Child Murderer Extraordinaire
Hugh Crain, the house’s original owner, is revealed to have murdered children to create his “eternal family.” He’s meant to be the embodiment of evil. Instead, he’s a floating face with all the menace of a DMV clerk. When Nell “defeats” him by declaring she’s not afraid, he gets sucked into a door like a vacuumed-up dust bunny.
It’s less climactic battle and more Roomba ad.
Dark Humor Highlights
-
The Dudleys, the creepy caretakers, literally vanish at night. Which is convenient, because they’d probably trip over all the CGI.
-
Liam Neeson spends half the movie explaining things that don’t matter. It’s less “scientific authority” and more “mansplaining ghost stories.”
-
Catherine Zeta-Jones’s Theo exists purely to wear sheer blouses and occasionally wink at Nell.
-
Owen Wilson yelling “No way!” at haunted furniture before losing his head. That’s not horror—it’s slapstick.
-
Nell ascending to heaven with ghost children at the end. Somewhere, Shirley Jackson is haunting this movie for butchering her novel.
Why It Fails: Horror Without Horror
The worst sin of The Haunting is that it isn’t scary. Not once. Not ever. It confuses “loud” with “terrifying,” “gaudy” with “atmospheric,” and “CGI ghosts” with “menace.” The characters are thin sketches, the plot is a mess, and the scares are buried under layers of digital gloss.
It should have been a chilling psychological ghost story. Instead, it’s Scooby-Doo with an $80 million budget.
Final Verdict: Haunted by Regret
The Haunting (1999) is a masterclass in how not to adapt Shirley Jackson. It’s overblown, underwritten, and about as frightening as a ride at Disneyland. With wasted talent, laughable CGI, and a climax that feels like a cutscene, it’s less a haunting and more a headache.
It made $180 million at the box office, which just proves audiences in 1999 were willing to buy anything with Liam Neeson and Catherine Zeta-Jones on the poster.
