Introduction: Lovecraft Gets the B-Movie Treatment
There are two kinds of H.P. Lovecraft adaptations: those that lean into the cosmic dread, existential horror, and ineffable terror of the Old Gods—and then there’s The Unnamable (1988), a film that decides the best way to interpret the master of cosmic horror is with horny college kids, a haunted house, and a monster that looks like it wandered in from a low-rent Legend of Zelda cosplay.
Jean-Paul Ouellette wrote, directed, and produced this cinematic séance, which is really just code for “nobody else wanted to be blamed.” It’s based on Lovecraft’s short story of the same name, except where Lovecraft’s “unnamable” horror was too strange and terrifying to describe, the movie makes it perfectly describable: it’s a woman in a monster mask with bad posture and a dental plan from hell.
Opening Scene: Daddy Issues, 18th-Century Edition
We open in the 1700s with Joshua Winthrop, a man whose greatest hobby seems to be unlocking doors he really shouldn’t. He has a daughter named Alyda, who also happens to be a screaming, banging demon that lives in his house. He tries soothing her with dad talk, which ends the way most horror dads’ lectures do—his face gets rearranged.
This should set the stage for a terrifying family curse. Instead, it sets the stage for a film that feels like a group project thrown together the night before it was due. The monster kills him, the camera zooms in dramatically, and you already know: this is going to be 90 minutes of pure VHS regret.
The College Kids: Scooby-Doo Without the Dog (or the Brains)
Fast-forward to the 1980s, where university students are lounging around in a graveyard because that’s apparently what passes for date night. Randolph Carter (Mark Kinsey Stephenson), the supposed Lovecraftian hero, tells ghost stories to his friends Joel and Howard. He’s a “scholar,” which here means he quotes myths while looking smug and constipated.
Joel decides it would be a great idea to spend the night in the haunted house. Because in horror films, stupidity is hereditary. Joel, of course, doesn’t come back. Shocker. Randolph’s reaction? A shrug and a half-hearted “I’ll get the flashlights.” If that’s the energy of your leading man, you know you’re in trouble.
Later, more cannon fodder arrives: two football bros and their girlfriends, Wendy and Tanya. Wendy is the standard-issue blonde whose sole purpose is to look good in half a nightgown, while Tanya is the kind of girl who follows the group into certain death because she’s “in love” with Howard, the human equivalent of wallpaper.
The Creature: The Nameless, Toothsome Wonder
Alyda Winthrop, the titular “Unnamable,” is supposed to be a terror beyond description. Instead, she looks like what happens if you mix leftover Exorcist prosthetics with a Party City clearance bin. The fangs are so oversized she can barely close her mouth, giving her the permanent expression of someone who just realized Taco Bell was a bad idea.
Rather than cosmic dread, she skulks around the house like a goth kid looking for snacks. Her kills aren’t terrifying—they’re clumsy, as if she’s improvising. Joel’s decapitated head rolls across the floor toward a topless Wendy, which should be horrifying but instead plays like a drunken bowling attempt.
Plot? What Plot?
The “plot” is essentially: monster house bad, horny kids go in, most die, Randolph fumbles around with the Necronomicon like a kid cramming before finals. The pacing lurches between endless walking through hallways and monster close-ups that reveal way too much of the cheap makeup.
Randolph eventually finds a spell to unlock the doors (which, naturally, have “locked themselves by magic”). He disappears into the catacombs, leaving everyone else to run around screaming. He shows up later with the big reveal that he’s basically been hanging out with skeletons under a tree. If you expected a climax of cosmic proportions, you’ll instead get Randolph looking mildly inconvenienced while Alyda gets yoinked out of the house by what looks like evil shrubbery.
Characters You Don’t Care About (and They Don’t Care About You)
-
Randolph Carter (Mark Kinsey Stephenson): Imagine a Lovecraft protagonist, but drained of charisma, fear, or intelligence. He studies grimoires while his friends are slaughtered, like the world’s worst Dungeons & Dragons dungeon master.
-
Howard Damon (Charles King): He’s in love with Wendy, then Tanya, then surviving, in that order. About as useful as a flashlight without batteries.
-
Joel (Mark Parra): The first one to die, and the only one you don’t miss. His decapitated head has more screen presence than he did alive.
-
Wendy (Laura Albert): Exists solely to scream, strip, and then die screaming. She’s like a contractual obligation to the slasher formula.
-
Tanya (Alexandra Durrell): Somehow survives, proving once again that in horror films, affection for the blandest male character is stronger than garlic against vampires.
The Necronomicon: Cliff Notes Edition
At one point, Randolph cracks open the Necronomicon to solve everything. In Lovecraft’s universe, this book is a tome of madness-inducing power. In this film, it’s basically a cheat code. Need to unlock a door? Boom, magic words. Need to stop the monster? Flip a few pages, mutter something in Latin, and wait for the tree roots to do their thing. It’s less “forbidden knowledge” and more “IKEA instruction manual.”
Production Values: Haunted House or Abandoned YMCA?
The house is supposed to be a gothic nightmare, but it looks like an old YMCA someone forgot to fumigate. The lighting is dim enough to hide the rubber monster suit, but bright enough to reveal the set decorator’s apathy. Every corridor looks the same, making you wonder if the actors just circled the same hallway for 40 minutes.
The gore is half-hearted at best—buckets of red syrup splashed around like someone lost a food fight. The scares are nonexistent unless you’re afraid of long pauses and actors trying to remember their lines.
Climax: The Shrubbery Saves the Day
The grand finale involves Randolph, armed with the Necronomicon, summoning tree roots to drag Alyda into the ground. Yes, the ultimate cosmic horror is defeated by landscaping. Imagine Evil Dead but without the fun, and you get the picture.
Howard and Tanya survive, proving that mediocrity is the ultimate defense against evil. Randolph pops up from the catacombs like he just finished spelunking at Disneyland, and the movie ends with all the gravitas of a wet paper bag.
Why It Fails (And Fails Again)
-
Lovecraft-lite: The source material is about indescribable horrors. The movie describes everything badly.
-
Zero Atmosphere: Haunted houses should feel oppressive. This one feels like a Halloween corn maze run by hungover teenagers.
-
Monster Overexposure: The unnamable creature would be scarier if we didn’t see her every five minutes, adjusting her dentures.
-
Characters You Root Against: When you find yourself cheering for the monster because everyone else is unbearable, you know the film failed.
Final Verdict: Unnamably Bad
The Unnamable takes the ineffable terror of Lovecraft and boils it down to a Scooby-Doo episode with extra gore and less charm. It’s neither scary nor faithful, and its biggest horror is realizing you wasted 88 minutes you’ll never get back.
If you want cosmic dread, read Lovecraft. If you want a fun haunted house, watch Evil Dead II. If you want to see a monster with a jaw problem chase bland undergrads around a YMCA, then sure, pop in The Unnamable. But don’t say you weren’t warned—sometimes the scariest thing is the VHS cover promising more than the film delivers.
